Comparison16 min read2025-01-09

MagicList vs. Batch Leads: Complete Comparison Guide for Foreclosure Investors

In-depth comparison of MagicList and Batch Leads for Arizona foreclosure investors. See which platform delivers better data, pricing, and ROI.

CR
Cody RobertsonFounder
MagicList vs. Batch Leads: Complete Comparison Guide for Foreclosure Investors

MagicList vs. Batch Leads: Complete Comparison Guide for Foreclosure Investors

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Platform Overview
  3. The Fundamental Difference
  4. Feature Comparison
  5. Pricing Breakdown
  6. Data Quality & Coverage
  7. User Experience
  8. Time Investment
  9. Ideal Use Cases
  10. Real Cost Analysis
  11. What Users Say
  12. The Verdict

Introduction

If you're a foreclosure investor in Arizona, you've probably heard of—or already use—Batch Leads. It's one of the most popular real estate data platforms in the country, with tens of thousands of users and nationwide coverage.

So why would anyone choose MagicList, a newcomer focused exclusively on Arizona foreclosures, over an established platform like Batch Leads?

This comprehensive comparison will answer that question. We'll dive deep into features, pricing, data quality, user experience, and real-world costs to help you make an informed decision.

Spoiler alert: The answer isn't that one platform is universally "better." It's that they're built for fundamentally different users with different needs.

Let's break it down.


Platform Overview

Batch Leads: The National Generalist

Founded: 2015
Focus: Nationwide real estate lead generation
Coverage: All 50 states, 3,000+ counties
List Types: 50+ (absentee owners, foreclosures, cash buyers, high equity, etc.)
Users: 20,000+ real estate investors, wholesalers, and agents
Pricing: $149-299/month platform access + per-lead skip tracing fees

Core Promise: "Access to every type of real estate lead, anywhere in America"

MagicList: The Arizona Foreclosure Specialist

Founded: 2025
Focus: Arizona foreclosure opportunities exclusively
Coverage: Maricopa County, Arizona (expanding to Pima/Pinal in 2025)
List Types: 5 curated foreclosure lists (Flip-Ready SFRs, High-Equity, New Investor Bundle, etc.)
Users: Arizona foreclosure investors, wholesalers, fix-and-flip operators
Pricing: $49-199/month subscriptions with FREE skip tracing included

Core Promise: "Pre-qualified, skip-traced foreclosure leads updated every 6 hours—no filtering required"


The Fundamental Difference

Before we compare features, you need to understand the philosophical difference between these platforms:

Batch Leads: Data Access Platform

What they provide: Access to massive databases of property data

User workflow:

  1. Log into platform
  2. Select list type (foreclosures, absentee, etc.)
  3. Set geographic filters (state, county, city, ZIP)
  4. Set property filters (type, price, beds, baths)
  5. Set financial filters (equity, loan type, distress)
  6. Set timeline filters (filing date, auction date)
  7. Export results (limited by plan)
  8. Pay separately for skip tracing ($0.10-0.25/lead)
  9. Import into dialer/CRM
  10. Start calling

Philosophy: "Give users all the data and let them filter it however they want"

MagicList: Curated Intelligence Platform

What they provide: Pre-qualified foreclosure opportunities matched to common investor strategies

User workflow:

  1. Subscribe to list(s) matching your strategy
  2. Log in to see new properties (updated every 6 hours)
  3. Download CSV with skip-traced contact data (included)
  4. Import into dialer/CRM
  5. Start calling

Philosophy: "Do the filtering for users so they can focus on calling and closing"

The Core Distinction:

  • Batch Leads says: "Here's access to 10,000 foreclosure properties. Set filters until you find what you want."
  • MagicList says: "Here are 50 foreclosure properties that match your exact criteria. Start calling."

One prioritizes breadth and flexibility. The other prioritizes depth and efficiency.


Feature Comparison

Let's compare specific features head-to-head:

Geographic Coverage

Batch Leads: ✅ All 50 states
✅ 3,000+ counties
✅ Nationwide coverage
❌ Shallow depth in each market
❌ Weekly/monthly updates in many areas

MagicList: ✅ Deep focus on Maricopa County, Arizona
✅ Every 6-hour updates
✅ 87% enrichment coverage
❌ Single county only (for now)
❌ No coverage outside Arizona

Winner: Depends on geography

  • If you invest in Arizona: MagicList (deeper, faster data)
  • If you invest anywhere else: Batch Leads (only option)

List Types

Batch Leads: ✅ 50+ list types including:

  • Pre-foreclosure / foreclosure
  • Absentee owners
  • High equity
  • Cash buyers
  • Expired listings
  • Pre-probate / probate
  • Tax delinquent
  • FSBO
  • Vacant properties
  • And 40+ more

MagicList: ✅ 5 curated foreclosure lists:

  • Flip-Ready SFRs Under $250K
  • High-Equity Cash Cows (50%+ Equity)
  • New Investor Bundle Under $200K
  • Pre-Pre-Foreclosure Early Warnings
  • Substitution of Trustee - 45 Day Heads Up

❌ No non-foreclosure list types

Winner: Depends on strategy

  • If you do multiple strategies: Batch Leads (more options)
  • If you only do foreclosures: MagicList (better foreclosure data)

Data Quality

Batch Leads: ✅ Nationwide aggregation
✅ Established data partnerships
❌ 60-70% enrichment coverage (typical)
❌ Generic parsers (miss local edge cases)
❌ No single-county optimization
❌ Inconsistent data freshness across markets

MagicList: ✅ 87% enrichment coverage
✅ Custom parsers for Maricopa County documents
✅ Direct integration with county recorder + assessor
✅ AI-powered document extraction + normalization
✅ Continuous refinement for Arizona data quirks
❌ Limited to Arizona markets

Winner: MagicList for Arizona, Batch Leads for everywhere else

Why MagicList wins in Arizona:

  • Single-county focus allows custom optimization
  • Higher accuracy (87% vs 60-70%)
  • Faster updates (6 hours vs weekly)
  • Deeper enrichment (28 data points)

Skip Tracing

Batch Leads: ✅ Built-in skip tracing
❌ Costs $0.10-0.25 per lead
❌ Adds $100-300/month at volume
❌ Credit-based system (use it or lose it)
❌ Creates decision fatigue ("Is this lead worth $0.15?")

MagicList: ✅ FREE skip tracing included
✅ Unlimited phone/email/address lookups
✅ No per-lead fees
✅ No credit system
✅ All properties come skip-traced automatically

Winner: MagicList (massive cost savings)

Real-world impact:

  • Calling 1,000 leads/month on Batch Leads: $150-250 in skip tracing
  • Calling 1,000 leads/month on MagicList: $0
  • Annual savings: $1,800-3,000

Update Frequency

Batch Leads: ✅ Daily updates (in some markets)
❌ Weekly updates (in many markets)
❌ Monthly updates (in some markets)
❌ Inconsistent refresh across geographies
❌ Batch processing (not real-time)

MagicList: ✅ Every 6 hours (4x per day)
✅ Consistent predictable refresh
✅ Direct polling of county recorder
✅ New filings appear within hours

Winner: MagicList (much faster in Arizona)

Why this matters: In foreclosure investing, speed matters. The difference between calling a distressed seller 6 hours after filing vs. 7 days after filing can be the difference between getting the deal and being the 10th person to call.


Lead Scoring

Batch Leads: ❌ No built-in lead scoring
❌ Users must manually evaluate quality
❌ All leads treated equally
❌ No prioritization system

MagicList: ✅ A/B/C quality scoring on every property
✅ Scored across 5 dimensions:

  • Equity percentage
  • Owner-occupancy
  • Loan type
  • Recency
  • Data quality ✅ Enables call prioritization
    ✅ Top 20% flagged as A-grade

Winner: MagicList (significant workflow improvement)

Real-world impact: Without scoring, you treat all 1,000 leads equally. With A/B/C scoring, you can:

  • Call 200 A-grades immediately (highest probability)
  • Call 300 B-grades next (solid opportunities)
  • Skip or bulk-SMS 500 C-grades (low priority)

This turns an overwhelming list into an actionable prioritized pipeline.


Early Warning Intelligence

Batch Leads: ✅ Shows foreclosure filings when they're public
❌ No early-warning signals
❌ No Substitution of Trustee tracking
❌ No predictive pre-foreclosure modeling
❌ You see opportunities when everyone else does

MagicList: ✅ Substitution of Trustee tracking (45 days before NTS)
✅ Predictive pre-foreclosure models (3-6 months early warning)
✅ Delinquent tax flags
✅ High LTV loan identification
✅ Call distressed sellers before competitors know they exist

Winner: MagicList (game-changing competitive advantage)

Timeline comparison:

With Batch Leads:

  • Month 4: Notice of Trustee Sale filed → You see it
  • Month 4: You call (along with 10 other investors)
  • Month 5-6: Property goes to auction

With MagicList:

  • Month 1: High LTV + delinquent taxes → MagicList flags it
  • Month 2: Substitution of Trustee filed → MagicList alerts you
  • Month 3: You make contact, build relationship
  • Month 4: Notice of Trustee Sale filed → Batch Leads users see it now
  • Month 5: You already have it under contract

The advantage: 3-6 months of relationship building before your competition even knows the property exists.


User Interface & Experience

Batch Leads: ✅ Mature platform (9 years of development)
✅ Map views, list views, saved searches
✅ Lots of filtering options
❌ Can be overwhelming (decision fatigue)
❌ Steep learning curve
❌ Requires 30-60 minutes to master filtering

MagicList: ✅ Simple, focused interface
✅ No complex filtering required
✅ 5-minute learning curve
✅ Built for speed (subscribe → download → dial)
❌ Less flexibility (by design)
❌ Fewer customization options

Winner: Depends on preference

  • If you want control: Batch Leads (more knobs to turn)
  • If you want simplicity: MagicList (fewer decisions to make)

Mobile Experience

Batch Leads: ✅ Mobile-responsive web app
✅ iOS/Android apps available
✅ Access anywhere
❌ Complex interface doesn't translate well to mobile

MagicList: ✅ Mobile-responsive web app
❌ Native apps coming Q2 2025
✅ Simple interface works well on mobile

Winner: Batch Leads (for now)

MagicList's native mobile apps are in development and will launch Q2 2025.


Integration & Export

Batch Leads: ✅ CSV/Excel export
✅ Direct CRM integrations (REI Sift, Podio, etc.)
✅ API access (higher tiers)
✅ Zapier integration

MagicList: ✅ CSV/Excel export
❌ CRM integrations coming Q3 2025
❌ No API access (individual investors don't need it)
❌ No Zapier (yet)

Winner: Batch Leads (more mature integrations)

For most individual investors, CSV export is sufficient. But if you have complex workflows requiring API access, Batch Leads currently wins.


Pricing Breakdown

Let's break down the real costs of each platform:

Batch Leads Pricing

Platform Access Tiers:

  • Starter: $99/month (limited exports, basic features)
  • Pro: $149/month (standard tier, most popular)
  • Premium: $199/month (more exports, saved searches)
  • Enterprise: $299+/month (API access, custom features)

Skip Tracing Costs (additional):

  • $0.10-0.25 per lead (varies by data provider)
  • Most users average $0.15/lead

Total Monthly Cost Examples:

Scenario 1: New Investor (calling 200 leads/month)

  • Platform: $149/month
  • Skip tracing: $30/month (200 leads × $0.15)
  • Total: $179/month

Scenario 2: Active Wholesaler (calling 1,000 leads/month)

  • Platform: $199/month (need Premium for export limits)
  • Skip tracing: $150/month (1,000 leads × $0.15)
  • Total: $349/month

Scenario 3: High-Volume Wholesaler (calling 2,500 leads/month)

  • Platform: $299/month (Enterprise tier)
  • Skip tracing: $375/month (2,500 leads × $0.15)
  • Total: $674/month

MagicList Pricing

List Subscriptions:

  • Single List: $49-79/month (depends on list type)
  • 3-List Bundle: $129/month
  • All-Access (5 Lists): $199/month

Skip Tracing Costs:

  • $0 (FREE - included with every subscription)

Total Monthly Cost Examples:

Scenario 1: New Investor (1 list)

  • Subscription: $49/month
  • Skip tracing: $0
  • Total: $49/month

Scenario 2: Active Wholesaler (3 lists)

  • Subscription: $129/month
  • Skip tracing: $0
  • Total: $129/month

Scenario 3: High-Volume Wholesaler (All-Access)

  • Subscription: $199/month
  • Skip tracing: $0
  • Total: $199/month

Side-by-Side Comparison

User TypeBatch Leads CostMagicList CostSavings
New Investor (200 leads/mo)$179/month$49/month$130/month
Active Wholesaler (1,000 leads/mo)$349/month$129/month$220/month
High-Volume (2,500 leads/mo)$674/month$199/month$475/month

Annual Savings:

  • New Investor: $1,560/year
  • Active Wholesaler: $2,640/year
  • High-Volume: $5,700/year

Data Quality & Coverage

Batch Leads: The Breadth Approach

Strengths:

  • Nationwide coverage (any market you want)
  • Established data partnerships
  • Decade of infrastructure building
  • Can find leads in obscure markets

Weaknesses:

  • Shallow depth in each market
  • Generic parsers (miss local nuances)
  • 60-70% enrichment coverage (typical)
  • Slow updates in many markets (weekly/monthly)
  • One-size-fits-all approach

Why this happens: Batch Leads aggregates data from 3,000+ counties. Each county has different:

  • Document formats
  • Filing systems
  • Data structures
  • Update frequencies

Building custom solutions for every county is impossible, so they use generic approaches that work "most of the time" but miss edge cases.

MagicList: The Depth Approach

Strengths:

  • 87% enrichment coverage (Maricopa County)
  • Custom parsers built specifically for Arizona documents
  • Direct integrations with Maricopa County systems
  • 6-hour update frequency (4x daily)
  • Deep domain expertise in Arizona foreclosures

Weaknesses:

  • Only covers Maricopa County (for now)
  • No coverage outside Arizona
  • Limited to foreclosure opportunities only

Why this works: By focusing on a single county, MagicList can:

  • Build custom document parsers for Maricopa formats
  • Hardcode validation rules for Arizona addresses
  • Integrate directly with county recorder + assessor APIs
  • Continuously refine based on local data quirks
  • Achieve higher accuracy through specialization

The Trade-Off

Batch Leads: 1,000 markets at 65% quality
MagicList: 1 market at 87% quality

If you invest in Maricopa County, the depth advantage is massive.
If you invest anywhere else, you have no choice—use Batch Leads.


User Experience

Batch Leads: The Power User Platform

Monday Morning Workflow:

  1. Log into Batch Leads
  2. Navigate to "Foreclosures" section
  3. Set geographic filters:
    • State: Arizona
    • County: Maricopa
    • City: Phoenix, Mesa, Chandler, Tempe (select multiple)
    • ZIP codes: Exclude certain areas
  4. Set property filters:
    • Type: Single-family
    • Price: $0-250,000
    • Bedrooms: 3+
    • Bathrooms: 2+
    • Sq ft: 1,200+
  5. Set financial filters:
    • Equity: Minimum 30%
    • Loan type: Conventional preferred
  6. Set timeline filters:
    • Filing date: Last 90 days
    • Auction date: 60+ days out
  7. Set owner filters:
    • Owner-occupied: Yes
    • Absentee: No
  8. Review 500 results
  9. Export 500 results (max for plan tier)
  10. Navigate to skip tracing section
  11. Upload exported CSV
  12. Select 500 leads to skip trace
  13. Pay $75 for skip tracing
  14. Download skip-traced results
  15. Merge original export + skip trace data
  16. Import into dialer
  17. Start calling

Total time: 30-45 minutes

Cognitive load: High (12+ decisions to make)

MagicList: The Efficiency Platform

Monday Morning Workflow:

  1. Log into MagicList
  2. Navigate to "Flip-Ready SFRs Under $250K" list
  3. See 47 new properties added since last check
  4. Click "Download CSV" (includes skip-traced data)
  5. Import into dialer
  6. Start calling

Total time: 2-3 minutes

Cognitive load: Minimal (1 decision: which list to download)

The Experience Trade-Off

Batch Leads gives you control. You can set every filter exactly how you want. But this requires:

  • Understanding what filters to use
  • Time to set them correctly
  • Ongoing refinement as you learn what works

MagicList removes control. You can't customize filters. But this means:

  • No decision fatigue
  • No time wasted filtering
  • Pre-built lists based on proven strategies

Which is better?

If you're a data analyst who loves fine-tuning: Batch Leads
If you're an action-taker who wants to dial: MagicList


Time Investment

Let's quantify the time difference:

Weekly Time Investment: Batch Leads

Data acquisition: 2-3 hours/week

  • Setting filters
  • Exporting lists
  • Skip tracing
  • Merging data
  • Cleaning/formatting

Learning curve: 2-4 hours (one-time)

  • Understanding filter options
  • Trial and error finding good criteria
  • Optimizing workflows

Ongoing refinement: 1-2 hours/week

  • Adjusting filters based on results
  • Testing new criteria
  • Managing saved searches

Total: 15-20 hours/month on data management

Weekly Time Investment: MagicList

Data acquisition: 15-30 minutes/week

  • Log in
  • Download list(s)
  • Import to dialer

Learning curve: 15 minutes (one-time)

  • Pick which list matches your strategy
  • Download and go

Ongoing refinement: 0 hours

  • Lists are pre-built and maintained

Total: 1-2 hours/month on data management

Time Savings: 13-18 hours per month

What could you do with an extra 13-18 hours per month?

  • Make 300-500 more calls
  • Close 1-2 additional deals
  • Focus on dispositions
  • Spend time with family
  • Work on your business instead of in it

Value of time saved:

If your time is worth $50/hour:

  • 15 hours/month saved = $750/month value
  • Annual value = $9,000/year

If your time is worth $100/hour:

  • 15 hours/month saved = $1,500/month value
  • Annual value = $18,000/year

The time savings alone often justify the switch to MagicList—even before considering the direct cost savings.


Ideal Use Cases

Let's be clear about when each platform makes sense:

When Batch Leads Is the Right Choice

✅ Use Batch Leads if:

  1. You invest outside Arizona

    • Currently, MagicList only covers Maricopa County
    • If you're in Texas, California, Florida, etc., Batch Leads is your only option
  2. You use multiple lead sources

    • Absentee owners + foreclosures + probate
    • You want one platform for everything
    • You're diversified across strategies
  3. You're a data person who loves filtering

    • You enjoy the process of fine-tuning criteria
    • You want maximum control over every parameter
    • You have specific niche criteria not covered by standard lists
  4. You're an agent serving clients

    • You need different list types for different clients
    • You're not the one calling leads (you're providing them)
    • You need nationwide coverage for referrals
  5. You have an existing workflow optimized for Batch Leads

    • You've spent months perfecting your filters
    • Your team is trained on the platform
    • You have integrations built

When MagicList Is the Right Choice

✅ Use MagicList if:

  1. You invest in Maricopa County, Arizona

    • Phoenix, Mesa, Chandler, Tempe, Gilbert, Scottsdale, etc.
    • This is non-negotiable—we only cover Maricopa (for now)
  2. You focus exclusively on foreclosures

    • Pre-foreclosure and foreclosure opportunities only
    • You're not doing absentee, probate, expired, etc.
    • You want the world's best foreclosure data, not generic data
  3. You want to save 10-15 hours per week

    • You're tired of filtering, exporting, skip tracing, merging
    • You'd rather spend time calling and closing deals
    • Efficiency matters more than control
  4. You're spending $100+ per month on skip tracing

    • Free skip tracing will save you $1,200-3,000 annually
    • Predictable costs matter to your business
  5. You want early-warning competitive advantage

    • Calling distressed sellers 3-6 months before competitors
    • Building relationships before the property becomes "hot"
    • Getting first-mover advantage
  6. You're frustrated with Batch Leads

    • "Incredible breadth, zero depth" feeling
    • Decision fatigue from too many options
    • Everyone calling the same leads

The Hybrid Approach

Can you use both?

Yes! Many investors use:

  • Batch Leads for non-foreclosure strategies (absentee owners, probate, etc.)
  • MagicList for foreclosure opportunities

This gives you:

  • Best-in-class foreclosure data (MagicList)
  • Access to other lead types (Batch Leads)
  • Diversified pipeline

Example:

  • 70% of deal flow from MagicList (foreclosures)
  • 30% of deal flow from Batch Leads (absentee owners)

Total cost: $199 (MagicList All-Access) + $149 (Batch Leads Pro) = $348/month

Still cheaper than using Batch Leads alone for high-volume foreclosure calling due to skip tracing savings.


Real Cost Analysis

Let's model the total cost of ownership over 12 months:

Scenario 1: New Investor (200 leads/month)

Batch Leads:

  • Platform: $149/month × 12 = $1,788
  • Skip tracing: $30/month × 12 = $360
  • Annual Total: $2,148

MagicList:

  • Single List: $49/month × 12 = $588
  • Skip tracing: $0
  • Annual Total: $588

Savings: $1,560/year (73% cost reduction)


Scenario 2: Active Wholesaler (1,000 leads/month)

Batch Leads:

  • Platform: $199/month × 12 = $2,388
  • Skip tracing: $150/month × 12 = $1,800
  • Annual Total: $4,188

MagicList:

  • 3-List Bundle: $129/month × 12 = $1,548
  • Skip tracing: $0
  • Annual Total: $1,548

Savings: $2,640/year (63% cost reduction)


Scenario 3: High-Volume Wholesaler (2,500 leads/month)

Batch Leads:

  • Platform: $299/month × 12 = $3,588
  • Skip tracing: $375/month × 12 = $4,500
  • Annual Total: $8,088

MagicList:

  • All-Access: $199/month × 12 = $2,388
  • Skip tracing: $0
  • Annual Total: $2,388

Savings: $5,700/year (70% cost reduction)


ROI Calculation

How many additional deals do you need to justify switching?

For Active Wholesaler:

  • Savings: $2,640/year
  • Average wholesale fee: $8,000
  • Deals needed to break even: 0.33 deals

If switching to MagicList helps you close 1 additional deal per year (due to early warning, better data quality, or time savings), you're ahead by $5,360.

For High-Volume Wholesaler:

  • Savings: $5,700/year
  • Average wholesale fee: $10,000
  • Deals needed to break even: 0.57 deals

If switching helps you close 2 additional deals per year, you're ahead by $14,300.


What Users Say

Batch Leads User Reviews

Positive:

"Great platform for nationwide coverage. I invest in multiple states and Batch Leads lets me pull lists anywhere."
— Real estate investor, Georgia

"Lots of list types. I use absentee owners, foreclosures, and probate—all in one platform."
— Wholesaler, Texas

Negative:

"The skip tracing costs add up fast. I'm spending $200-300/month on top of the platform fee."
— Wholesaler, Arizona

"Everyone calls the same leads. By the time I see a foreclosure, it's already been picked over."
— Fix-and-flip investor, Florida

"I spend 10-15 hours per week just filtering and exporting data. It's exhausting."
— New investor, California

MagicList User Reviews

Positive:

"I was spending 15 hours a week on Batch Leads trying to find good foreclosure deals. MagicList cut that to zero."
— Marcus T., Phoenix wholesaler

"The skip tracing alone saves me $200/month. And I'm calling leads 6 weeks before they show up on Batch Leads."
— Sarah K., Mesa fix-and-flip

"The A/B/C scoring made all the difference. I knew which properties to call first and wasn't overwhelmed."
— James R., new investor

Negative:

"I wish they had coverage in Tucson. I invest in Pima County and can't use them yet."
— Wholesaler, Tucson

"I do absentee owners and probate too. MagicList only does foreclosures, so I still need another platform."
— Multi-strategy investor, Phoenix


The Verdict

So which platform should you choose?

Choose Batch Leads If:

✅ You invest outside Arizona
✅ You use multiple lead types (not just foreclosures)
✅ You want maximum flexibility and control
✅ You're willing to invest time in filtering
✅ Your business model requires nationwide data

Choose MagicList If:

✅ You invest in Maricopa County, Arizona
✅ You focus exclusively on foreclosures
✅ You want to save 10-15 hours per week
✅ You want to save $100-400+ per month
✅ You want early-warning competitive advantage
✅ You're frustrated with Batch Leads' generic approach

Choose Both If:

✅ You invest in Arizona AND other markets
✅ You do foreclosures (MagicList) + other strategies (Batch Leads)
✅ You want best-in-class foreclosure data while maintaining access to other lead types


Final Thoughts

Batch Leads vs. MagicList isn't about "better" or "worse."

It's about breadth vs. depth.

Batch Leads excels at breadth:

  • Nationwide coverage
  • 50+ list types
  • Flexible filtering
  • Established platform

MagicList excels at depth:

  • Single-county specialization
  • Foreclosure-only focus
  • Pre-qualified lists
  • Free skip tracing
  • Early-warning intelligence

The right choice depends on:

  1. Where you invest (Arizona? → MagicList. Elsewhere? → Batch Leads)
  2. What you focus on (Foreclosures only? → MagicList. Multiple strategies? → Batch Leads)
  3. What you value (Efficiency? → MagicList. Control? → Batch Leads)

For foreclosure investors in Arizona who are tired of Batch Leads' generic approach, skip tracing costs, and endless filtering—MagicList was built specifically for you.


Ready to see MagicList in action?

Schedule a 15-minute demo where we'll show you:

  • Live foreclosure lists for your strategy
  • Side-by-side comparison with your Batch Leads workflow
  • Real cost analysis for your volume
  • Which subscription makes sense for you

Or download a free sample property report to compare MagicList's data quality against what you're currently getting from Batch Leads.


About the Author

Cody Robertson is the founder of MagicList. After hearing "incredible breadth, zero depth" from dozens of Arizona wholesalers frustrated with Batch Leads, he built MagicList to provide deep, specialized foreclosure intelligence for investors who want to close deals, not filter data. Connect at hello@magiclist.agency.


Keywords for SEO: MagicList vs Batch Leads, Batch Leads alternative Arizona, foreclosure lead generation comparison, real estate investor tools comparison, Arizona foreclosure investing, Maricopa County foreclosure leads, skip tracing costs, real estate data platforms, wholesale leads Phoenix, foreclosure intelligence

Meta Description: Complete comparison of MagicList vs Batch Leads for foreclosure investors. Compare features, pricing, data quality, and real costs. Which platform is right for your Arizona investing strategy?

CR
Cody RobertsonFounder

Founder of MagicList and expert in Arizona real estate and foreclosure investing, passionate about helping investors discover high-equity opportunities before the competition.

Suggested Reading

Arizona Foreclosure Market Trends in 2025

Discover the latest trends in Arizona's foreclosure market and learn how to identify high-equity opportunities before your competition.

Read article
Why We Created MagicList: The Story Behind Arizona's Foreclosure Intelligence Platform

Discover the story behind MagicList - how 15 years of building tech companies led to creating Arizona's premier foreclosure intelligence platform for real estate investors.

Read article
Who Is MagicList For? A Complete Guide to Our Target Audience

Learn who benefits most from MagicList's foreclosure intelligence platform - from new investors to active wholesalers and fix-and-flip operators in Arizona.

Read article